Blogging A to Z: Day 23 – Whodunit: The classic “whodunit” format of cozy mysteries

Hey there, friends! Do you love curling up with a good mystery novel, wrapped in a cozy blanket and sipping on a cup of tea? Well, then you’re in the right place because today we’re talking about the classic “whodunit” format of cozy mysteries.

Now, I know what you’re thinking. “Jen, what the heck is a cozy mystery?” Well, my darlings, cozy mysteries are a sub-genre of crime fiction that are typically set in small, intimate communities with a limited number of suspects. Think of it like a murder mystery party, but without the awkward socializing and with much higher stakes.

The “whodunit” format is one of the most popular and enduring formats in cozy mysteries. It’s the kind of mystery where a crime has been committed, a limited pool of suspects are introduced, and you, the reader, are left to figure out who the culprit is. It’s like a puzzle for your brain, and who doesn’t love a good brain-puzzle?

So, if you’re ready to dive into the world of cozy mysteries and whodunits, then stick around. In this blog post, we’ll be breaking down the elements of a classic whodunit, exploring why they’re so darn popular, and even giving you some tips on how to write your own.

But before we get started, I just want to let you know that this post contains affiliate links. That means that if you make a purchase through one of my links, I’ll earn a small commission at no extra cost to you. And if you enjoy this post, please make sure to like, comment, subscribe, and share it with your fellow cozy mystery lovers. And if you prefer to listen to your blogs, you can even check out the audio version on my podcast, available on Spotify and Amazon Music. Let’s get to it!

The elements of a whodunit are like a recipe for a delicious mystery cake. You start with a crime – like someone eating the last slice of pie in the fridge – and then you sprinkle in a limited pool of suspects. Maybe it was your sister, who has always had a weakness for pie, or your dad, who is notorious for sneaking midnight snacks.

But it’s not enough to just have suspects. You need clues. Maybe there’s a dollop of whipped cream on the counter or a crumb on the floor. These are the breadcrumbs that lead the detective – or you, the reader – down the path to the truth.

Of course, nothing is ever that easy. That’s where red herrings come in. They’re like raisins in a cake. Sure, they add flavor, but sometimes they get stuck in your teeth and you’re left wondering if it was the raisin or a cavity that’s causing the pain.

But fear not! The detective is on the case. With their keen eye for detail and their ability to connect the dots, they solve the crime and bring the culprit to justice. It’s like the icing on the cake – sweet, satisfying, and oh so delicious.

So the next time you’re reading a whodunit, remember the recipe. Crime, suspects, clues, red herrings, and a brilliant detective to tie it all together. And if you’re feeling adventurous, try baking a mystery cake of your own. Just don’t forget the whipped cream – it’s the most important clue of all.

Cozy mysteries are like a delicious pot of chili on a cold winter day – comforting, satisfying, and perfect for curling up with a blanket and a cat. But what sets the whodunit format apart from other genres? Well, for one, it engages the reader’s mind like a good Sudoku puzzle. You’ll be scratching your head, scribbling notes, and trying to piece together the clues like a private eye with a magnifying glass.

And when you finally do solve the mystery? Oh, the sense of satisfaction is better than a warm brownie with a scoop of vanilla ice cream. You’ll feel like a genius, like Sherlock Holmes or Miss Marple. You’ll be yelling “aha!” and pumping your fists in the air like you just won the lottery.

But let’s not forget the tension and suspense that builds throughout the story. It’s like watching a horror movie, but without the gratuitous violence and jump scares. You’ll be on the edge of your seat, heart racing, wondering who could have done such a dastardly deed. And when the reveal finally comes, it’s like a pressure valve being released. You can finally relax and enjoy the aftermath.

And of course, cozy mysteries are just plain entertaining and enjoyable to read. They’re like a warm hug from a dear friend or a good belly laugh after a long day. You’ll get lost in the world of the story, and before you know it, the hours will have flown by. So go ahead, pour yourself a cup of tea, snuggle up with a good book, and let the whodunit format work its magic on you.

Now, let’s talk about some of the most famous whodunits in the cozy mystery genre. If you’re new to cozy mysteries, you might want to start with these classics before moving on to more modern works. They’re like the Beatles of cozy mysteries, except without the weird haircuts and British accents (well, except for one of them).

First up, we have Agatha Christie’s “Murder on the Orient Express.”

This book has it all – a train, a snowdrift, and a murder. And who better to solve the crime than the fastidious Hercule Poirot, with his waxed mustache and impeccable manners? Seriously, if you ever find yourself on a train with Poirot, just fess up to the murder right away and save yourself the trouble.

Next, we have Arthur Conan Doyle’s “The Hound of the Baskervilles.”

This one has a creepy old mansion, a cursed family, and a giant spectral hound. I mean, who doesn’t love a good spectral hound, right? And let’s not forget about the brilliant Sherlock Holmes, who always manages to solve the case just in the nick of time. If you’re ever cursed by a spectral hound, just give ol’ Sherlock a call. He’ll know what to do.

Moving on, we have Dorothy L. Sayers’ “The Nine Tailors.”

This book has bells, lots and lots of bells. And a dead body, of course. It’s like “The Sound of Music,” but with murder instead of singing. And let’s not forget about the dashing Lord Peter Wimsey, with his impeccable fashion sense and charming wit. If you ever need to solve a murder while also looking fabulous, Lord Peter is your man.

Last but not least, we have Louise Penny’s “A Fatal Grace.”

This book has ice, lots and lots of ice. And a murder, naturally. It’s like “Frozen,” but with murder instead of singing. And let’s not forget about the intrepid Chief Inspector Armand Gamache, who always manages to catch the killer despite the harsh Canadian winters. If you’re ever stuck in a snowdrift with a murderer, just call up Chief Inspector Gamache. He’ll dig you out and solve the case at the same time.

So there you have it – some of the most famous whodunits in the cozy mystery genre. Just remember, if you ever find yourself in a cozy mystery novel, try not to get murdered. It’s generally not very comfortable.

Buckle up, my friends, because we’re about to dive into the thrilling world of writing a cozy mystery whodunit. Now, I’m not a detective myself, but I’ve spent many an hour devouring whodunit books while drinking copious amounts of coffee. So trust me, I know a thing or two about crafting a mystery that will keep your readers on the edge of their seats.

First things first, start with the crime. And no, I’m not talking about the time I accidentally set my hair on fire while trying to light a scented candle. I’m talking about a crime that will really grab your readers’ attention. Think outside the box – a missing garden gnome, a stolen recipe, or even a murder (if you’re feeling bold). Just make sure it’s something that will pique your readers’ interest and keep them invested throughout the story.

Next, you need to develop some interesting and unique suspects. I mean, sure, you could have your boring old neighbor Bob as the culprit, but where’s the fun in that? Get creative with your characters – maybe the local baker has been embezzling funds to support his secret gambling addiction, or the friendly librarian has a dark past that she’s been desperately trying to keep hidden. The key here is to keep your readers guessing until the very end.

Of course, no whodunit would be complete without a trail of clues and red herrings to keep your readers guessing. Maybe there’s a mysterious note left at the scene of the crime, or a footprint that doesn’t match any of the suspects’ shoes. And don’t forget about the red herrings – throw in some false leads and dead ends to really keep your readers on their toes.

Finally, it’s time to write a satisfying resolution. This is where you tie everything together and reveal the true culprit (or culprits, if you’re feeling really sneaky). Make sure the resolution is logical and makes sense based on the clues you’ve provided throughout the story. And of course, make sure it’s satisfying for your readers. After all, there’s nothing worse than investing hours of your time into a whodunit only to be let down by a lackluster ending.

So there you have it, my fellow cozy mystery enthusiasts – the key elements to writing a killer (pun intended) whodunit. Now go forth and let your inner Agatha Christie shine! And for the love of all things holy, don’t set your hair on fire.

In conclusion, cozy mysteries are the perfect combination of suspense, intrigue, and humor, and the whodunit format is a tried and true favorite among readers. From the clues to the red herrings, every element of a whodunit is crafted to keep you guessing until the very end. And isn’t that the best part? That sense of satisfaction when you finally figure it out? (Or, if you’re like me, the sense of confusion when you’re wrong and everything you thought you knew was a lie.)

But the best part of whodunits is that they’re not just entertaining, they’re inspiring. If you’re a writer, try your hand at crafting your own whodunit. Who knows? You might be the next Agatha Christie, but with more puns and obscure references to pop culture. And if you’re a reader, keep exploring the wonderful world of cozy mysteries. There are so many incredible authors out there, each with their own unique twist on the classic whodunit format.

So, like, comment, share, and subscribe to stay up-to-date on all the latest cozy mystery news and releases. Who knows? Maybe we’ll even solve a real-life mystery together. Or at the very least, we’ll have some laughs along the way.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

Blog at

Up ↑

%d bloggers like this: